Don't read this if you love your healthcare plan and support insurance companies being allowed to price you out of your access to necessary healthcare. 

10/3/2025
Eileen Weber

Because as a nurse for 48 years who saw everything imaginable, including the results of gross social injustice, in the emergency department, I'm compelled to speak out against our Republican-led government cutting healthcare access for the many in order to provide lucrative tax cuts for the wealthiest. 

Almost thirty-four years ago, the Star Tribune published my first-hand account of a woman I cared for in the middle of the night who was forced to visit two emergency rooms for treatment of a worsening bladder infection because of her insurer's shortsighted rules. The insurer said yes to the first ER visit at another hospital, but no to the relatively inexpensive antibiotic she needed, and could have received at the first hospital if the hospital pharmacy had been covered by her "plan." But it wasn't, and she was broke, so she left without the antibiotic. When she got sicker, she ended up coming to my publicly-supported ER for better care. Even though she was on a public program (think Medicare and Medicaid/Medical Assistance), healthcare plans like hers received legislative permission to take our tax dollars and use them as they saw fit in providing (or not) access to necessary health care. In my sick patient's case, how the "healthcare plan" saw fit to use our tax dollars was to deny access to inexpensive medication and use much, much, much more expensive ER care instead. ER care that taxpayers funded.

“Deja vu all over again.”

— Babe Ruth

Trump, Kennedy, and their unquestioning Republican devotees want tax cuts for the wealthiest to be subsidized by cutting support for Obamacare coverage and Medicaid/Medical Assistance. As a direct result, major health care plans who provide Obamacare-mandated coverage in Minnesota, with the state's blessing, will hike premiums (their middle-man, worthless take of our precious dollars), if they continue coverage at all (see the cancellation of Medicare Advantage plans). Sick people can lose their homes or their lives, but the state will make sure private healthcare plans are protected. Our government should protect us and our ability to get the care we need when we need it. It should not fail that imperative in order to protect the bottom lines of profit-driven healthcare plans.

Then and now, insurance companies, with the blessings of our elected representatives, are dictating the cost of and access to necessary healthcare. Republicans clearly believe that the right to life ends when the umbilical cord is cut.

Healthcare is a human right, not a privilege for those lucky enough to have coverage. The only place that right is enshrined in law is in the ER, where we are forbidden from turning anyone away.

With more people turning to the ER when they can no longer afford insurance, the backlog and wait times will severely increase. 

That's if the ER stays open at all. Clinics and hospitals in rural MN and US are closing. Ten rural MN clinics are closing, 46% of MN rural hospitals operate at a loss, and over 700 rural hospitals in the US are at risk of closing. Why do Republican legislators, many from rural areas, find this an acceptable tradeoff for increasing the wealth of the already wealthy?

In Senate District 41, ask Reps. Tom Dippel and Wayne Johnson that question.

Do not accept that they have no say in federal policy - they have also had no objection. If they really represented the best interests of their constituents, they would join those who are up in arms and fighting these cruel, shortsighted cuts to Minnesotans' quality of life.